@ 26cdfd8d:245f55f1

# Existe livre arbítrio? #curiosidades #Bíblia #Cristianismo #cristão Existe livre arbítrio? Alguns cristãos negariam afimando que a Bíblia não fala nada a respeito disso e esse termo duplo nem sequer consta lá. O que é verdade, embora também não conste os termos "Trindade", "milênio", nem mesmo a palavra Bíblia ou vários outros termos amplamente usados pelos cristãos. Também é inquestionável que as escrituras falam sobre liberdade humana antes e após a queda (entrada do pecado). O homem é incapaz de fazer escolhas certas e precisa de Deus, daí para frente, há liberdade ou a graça irresistível não lhe deixaria escolha? ### O que o pecado fez conosco A primeira transgressão tornou a nossa natureza corrupta e sujeitou toda a raça a uma infeliz escravidão que dura milênios. Antes disso, cristãos que crêem na literalidade do relato da criação são unânimes em acreditar que o casal, criado perfeito, não era livre por natureza e tomou uma decisão voluntária quando pecou, já que o pecado nenhum poder tinha sobre eles, de antemão e tampouco a graça de Deus mostrava-se coercitiva. A partir daí o pecado e a morte passaram a todos os descendentes de Adão, porque todos, com exceção de Jesus, pecaram, e não fizeram isso porque tiveram outra escolha, mas porque o pecado que habita neles é compulsório. Sem uma intervenção divina é certa a perdição de todos. Nos dias anteriores ao dilúvio, Deus percebeu que o homem se havia corrompido de tal forma que achou melhor destruí-lo de sobre a face da terra. Seu Espírito não contenderia para sempre com eles, disse, mas determinou um tempo de cento e vinte anos para que o dilúvio viesse. A luz de Deus havia brilhado especialmente através de Enoque e Noé, pessoas que andavam com Deus. Enoque profeta e Noé pregador da justiça. Enquanto o Espírito de Deus encontrava resistência ferrenha no coração da maioria, esses dois homens usaram do poder que Deus sempre havia dado aos homens de sujeitar o pecado, mas que eles nem sempre queriam usar. A Caim foi prometido que Deus lhe daria capacidade de dominar o pecado e seu desejo, mas ele deu vazão à ira que sentia pela rejeição de sua oferta e matou seu irmão. Teria Deus se arrependido de criar a humanidade se ela definitivamente não tivesse um meio de estar em harmonia com Ele? Seria muito estranho pensar que a geração antidiluviana estava apenas vivendo da única forma como poderia viver e Deus ainda se ressentisse como se esperasse que ela fosse diferente, inclusive enviando Seu Espírito para contender com eles, da mesma forma como em Gálatas é dito que a carne milita contra o Espírito e o Espírito contra a carne. Embora fique claro que a cruz, ressurreição e ascensão de Cristo foram fator determinantes para que o Espírito Santo viesse em plenitude de poder, inclusive impressionando as mentes com a história do amor de Cristo tão grandemente demonstrado, ainda seria banalizar o ministério que o Espírito Santo realizava antes do dilúvio acreditar que fosse totalmente ineficaz. A imagem clara que temos é que o Espírito estava agindo nos antidiluvianos para mortificar a carne deles, para eles obterem o poder de sujeitar o pecado, como Caim também poderia, mas eles resistiram. Noé não resistiu. E não foi pelas obras que ele conquistou a salvação, mas, segundo está escrito "Noé achou graça aos olhos de Deus". Mais tarde Jesus diria que "aqueles que buscam, encontram", Noé encontrou a graça quando os antidiluvianos encontravam o que buscavam "comiam, bebiam, casavam, davam-se em casamento", "porque todas essas coisas os gentios procuram", mas só Noé "[buscou] em primeiro lugar o Seu Reino e a Sua justiça". ### A busca "Não há quem entenda, não há quem busque a Deus, todos se extraviaram e juntamente se fizeram inúteis". Esse é o quadro da humanidade, terrível, mas honesto. Quando Jesus chega para unir Deus aos homens pela sua carne. A Bíblia aprensenta Jesus como aquele que busca os que nem querem ser encontrados, imagine então, se eles buscariam a Deus de espontânea vontade... Primeiro porque não conheciam a Deus e tinham pavor da imagem distorcida. Eles tiveram consciência da misério dos seus pecados, mas a chance de buscarem a solução com Aquele que imaginavam iria destruí-los, era ínfima e dentre aqueles que professavam lealdade, boa parte fazia"por medo da morte". Se a iniciativa não fosse de Deus não haveria salvação de nenhum homem. Deus buscou a humanidade como uma ovelha entre cem, na revelação de Si mesmo atraiu cada um deles individualmente para Si. Embora o monergismo (visão cristã que entende que a soberania de Deus exclui a liberdade humana) afirme que a expiação, revelação e eleição não inclua todas as pessoas, Ele nos envolve em uma missão para todos com o intuito de que "todos os homens se salvem e cheguem ao conhecimento da verdade". Deus se torna acessível através da pregação quando diz que havendo quem pregue, ouvirão, crerão e invocarão Seu nome para serem salvos. Deus diz ao homem: "Busque a meu rosto" e o coração do homem humilde diz: "Ao teu rosto, Senhor, buscurei". Deus é quem chama, mas poucos atendem. Deus assim se expressa: "Porque eu clamei e recusastes, estendi a minha mão e não houve quem desse atenção" sobre a vocação e porque são poucos os escolhidos. ### Escolhidos Também conhecidos como eleitos, são aqueles que Deus primeiramente chamou e puderam ser provados, experimentados, e tomaram parte em alguma função na obra de Deus. São escolhidos para tomar parte na obra. Jacó foi escolhido para ser o primogênito e líder espiritual da sua família, isso não quer dizer que Esaú está perdido, como alguns afirmam. O fato de ele não ter encontrado lugar de arrependimento depois de vender a primogenitura quer dizer que não poderia voltar a ser o primogênito, mas não que a sua profanidade não pudesse ser perdoada e sua vida não pudesse ser redimida. O caso do sacerdote Eli ajuda a ilustrar bem o que significa ser um escolhido. Quando veio um homem de Deus falar com Eli, dizendo que ele era o escolhido como sacerdote. Mas pelo modo como ele e seus filhos tratavam os sacrifícios, Deus sustou a promessa e disse que, apesar de ter falado que ele e sua andaria perpetuamente diante dEle, Deus conclui dizendo: "Longe de mim tal coisa" e "aos que me honram, honrarei". Saul também é outro exemplo de alguém que Deus escolheu. Antes que o povo se interessasse por Saul como rei, Deus já tinha mandado que ele fosse ungido. A escolha foi de Deus. Deus colocou sobre ele o Seu Espírito, ele profetizava, porém saiu dos propósitos de Deus e, no final, além de ser possesso de demônios, ainda morreu de uma forma muito vergonhosa que aparenta ter sido sua perdição eterna. Escolhidos também podem ser rejeitados. Se a graça de Deus fosse irresistível na vida dos escolhidos, Eli e Saul não teriam fracassado. Nem se pode argumentar que a Antiga Aliança exigia obediência estrita e não havia graça como hoje, porque o próximo rei pecou muito mais que Eli e Saul juntos e permaneceu no trono e na graça de Deus, não foi amaldiçoado, nem morto como merecia, nem espírito imundo o possuiu. O que intui-se é que Eli e Saul também estavam sob a graça e não fizeram caso. ### A liberdade dos filhos de Deus Cristo prometeu: "Se o Filho do Homem vos libertar, verdadeiramente sereis livres". Todos os cristãos reconhecem que liberdade mesmo é poder vencer a escravidão do pecado para servir a Cristo como SENHOR, pressupondo uma relação escravo-SENHOR. Contudo Jesus quebrou a ideia de um assenhoramento rigoroso do tipo como é ensinado na doutrina da graça irresistível. Jesus os chamou de "amigos". Um senhor que é amigo é diferente de um estranho que não importa contigo. Dizer que somos livres parece algo muito simples, mas qual seria a natureza dessa liberdade? Era algo muito interessante que até os falsos irmãos se intrometiam na igreja para expiar essa tal liberdade. Teria Jesus devolvido o arbítrio que Adão e Eva tinham antes do pecado? Paulo e claro ao falar aos livres para tomarem cuidado para não tornar a "colocar-[se] debaixo do jugo da servidão", ou seja, para não se entregar ao antigo senhor: o pecado. Está claro que os filhos de Deus, regenerados, livres, cheios do Espírito Santo, poderiam escolher abandonar a liberdade de forma voluntária. Pensemos em Judas Iscariotes e Ananias e Safira, exemplos relativamente mais recentes do que os anteriores. Judas recebeu o Espírito e dom para curar, expelir demônios, ele teve o poder de anunciar o Reino de Deus para seus compatriotas, mas a avareza o fez desperdiçar tudo. Mas seria Judas um bom exemplo se ele estava "predestinado" a trair? Com certeza, especialmente porque isso mostra que mesmo em meio ao conceito de predestinação a liberdade fala mais alto. Jesus lhe deu todos os meios para vencer sua fraqueza, mas ele exerceu sua escolha, embora não fosse totalmente livre, por não ter se firmado na liberdade de Cristo, o fato de ter escolhido o caminho da servidão já é uma escolha voluntária e livre, o que ele fez depois é um risco que ele decidiu correr quando realmente ainda poderia escolher livremente. Como Adão, antes de morder o fruto ele escolheu livremente, mas o que ele faria depois disso é um risco que ele decidiu correr. Por pelo menos dois motivos Cristo poderia atestar que ele falharia e todos eles estão ligados à onisciência. Deus sabe o fim desde o princípio, o que não significa que sua onisciência seja causativa interferindo nas escolhas pessoais. Jesus só estava dando um spoiler de um filme que ele já havia visto, assim como eu posso fazer enquanto assistimos um filme que eu já vi, mas isso não quer dizer que eu escrevi o roteiro do filme e obriguei a personagem a fazer aquilo. O segundo ponto e não menos importante, Deus conhece cada um individualmente. Jesus sabia que colocado naquelas situações, ele escolheria daquela forma. Se eu sei que minha irmã gosta de pizza doce, eu posso até levar uma outra salgada, mas eu tenho uma razoável certeza de qual delas ela irá escolher, acontece que Jesus não erra. Ananias e Safira passoram pelo avivamento da primeira ou segunda descida do Espírito Santo, eram cristãos genuínos e, por conta de uma fraqueza semelhante a de Judas, tiveram um fim terrível por um juízo divino. Quando eles venderam sua propriedade, combinaram mentir para ficar com parte da propriedade. Deus foi mais duro com Ananias, que foi o idealizador do plano diabólico, e sua execução foi quase imediata. Já Safira ainda teve uma chance de responder por quanto teria vendido a propriedade. Se tivesse sido honesta, teria sido poupada do juízo. Ambos foram fulminados e a igreja recebeu um exemplo contra a hipocrisia e engano diante de Deus. Eles voluntariamente escolharem não se firmarem na liberdade de Cristo e caíram pelo próprio engano que eles intentavam enganar a igreja e a Deus - quanta ingenuidade achar que Deus poderia ser enganado. ### Responsabilidade e glória A liberdade vem com responsabilidade. Um ser escravo, ainda que de uma maravilhosa graça irresistível não pode ser responsabilizado. Sem responsabilidade até a noção de justiça e juízo não tem sentido. Como alguém poderia ser condenado por não crer no nome do Filho de Deus se a fé não lhe foi concedida? Agora se ele resistiu à fé, a sua condenação é mais do que justa. Considerar que o pecador é livre para resistir ou se entregar a Cristo não é glorificar aos homens pela sua própria participação na salvação de suas vidas? Está escrito que a salvação vem somente pela graça, se o sangue não tivesse sido derramado, ninguém poderia ser salvo. A obra redentiva é de Deus e a glória é dEle. E a fé, vem de Deus, "conforme a porção que Deus deu a cada um". Então se cada um tem uma porção de fé, porque não são todos cristãos? A fé torna todos imunes a dúvidas? Pedro estava caminhando pela fé e submergiu. Jesus o ajudou e fez a pergunta chave: Por que duvidaste? O homem tem a liberdade de duvidar, de desconfiar. Quando a fé é exercida, é graças a Deus, mas quando ele duvida, faz o que lhe é próprio. Deus também não pode ser responsabilizado por tudo porque é Soberano. O mal não surgiu por sua vontade soberana. Conforme está escrito em Daniel "um grande conflito". Se a soberania de Deus significasse controle absoluto, Deus não seria chamado de "SENHOR dos Exércitos", "SENHOR das guerras", Ele simplesmente faria o que quisesse sem qualquer oposição. Um dia Deus chamou o povo amado disse: "Tenho proposto a vida e morte, a bênção e a maldição; escolha, pis, a vida, para que você e tua descendência vivam". Deus sempre guia. Ele vai à frente como o Pastor, não é um boiadeiro que vai por trás dando tiros para o alto impelindo a gado a seguir, mas é um Pastor com uma doce voz: Vem, segue-Me. Quem ouvir pode abrir a porta e ceiar com Ele. Você crê nisso a ponto de obedecer para a glória de Deus?

@ 26cdfd8d:245f55f1

# Dia dos símbolos nacionais Os símbolos: bandeira, selo, armas e hino nacional. Gosto do Brasil, mas não ligo muito para essas coisas e, sobre o hino nacional, detesto.

@ 521059d9:2341d457

Both sides have openly 🔥 😀 said 🎉 😀 🔥 they 👍 want to 😂 censor. 🌈

@ 39231604:6434eaac

Depends on the definition of *stop*. Responsively Resistant. Allows spamming at a cost. Bitcoin fees are standing by, ready to *make them pay* Spammers pay, then pay, then keep paying……Eventually they run out of resources. SATs have then flowed to miners. On a long enough time window, fees *stop* spammers and scammers and those who censor

@ 32e18276:5c68e245

I love when bitcoiners think they are holier than thou because they have fees and PoW, but they still can’t stop spam in blocks. At least with relays we don’t have centralized decision making or storage, and can try different approaches (pyramid relay, pow relay, wot relay, ip rate limiting relay, ai anti spam relay, whitelist relay, rawdog yolo relay) and with outbox we can weave them together in an automatic way nostr:note19hle60l5fqq3u5d8nuvm0hgdxs0nuu7wa72ms2kv586g2p90639sa55hfk

@ 26cdfd8d:245f55f1

nostr:nprofile1qqstwfzqv4d68znj6tyn0w58fw58nqu3khu5enpyull7r8nwf2vc9rspzemhxue69uhhyetvv9ujuurjd9kkzmpwdejhgqguwaehxw309ahx7um5wghx6at5d9h8jampd3kx2apwvdhk6qg5waehxw309aex2mrp0yhxgctdw4eju6t03rag4u, nostr:nprofile1qqszmkf9pv50vtruf9q4w32z85qlllm5ppx78mt72ymes5a7d6fgquspr3mhxue69uhkummnw3ezucnfw33k76twv4ezuum0vd5kzmqpp4mhxue69uhkummn9ekx7mqpzemhxue69uhhyetvv9ujumn0wd68ytnzv9hxg3gcrg4... Chegou o dia da polêmica! Se preparem...

@ c4f5e7a7:8856cac7

Are there any S19 space heater prints? #asknostr #3dprinting

@ 32e18276:5c68e245

Last night i was on the couch playing oldschool RuneScape on my phone while my airpods were connected to my apple tv with a show on. I dunno if android devices can do that but connecting my airpods to my tv is such a killer feature i use all the time since my couch is far away.

@ 17538dc2:71ed77c4

Thanks, jotted down here. https://github.com/nostrability/nostrability/issues/89#issuecomment-2356689164 Thats an individual app design decision cc nostr:npub16c0nh3dnadzqpm76uctf5hqhe2lny344zsmpm6feee9p5rdxaa9q586nvr

@ c6f7077f:ad5d48fd

>Redditor posts picture of his brain MRI >Large portion of his brain is missing >Several other Redditors chime in with their own MRIs >They're all missing large portions of their brains It's all starting to make sense now. https://image.nostr.build/66ec758362cfbf768d0c05905abf76af8d99bbc57b8a2bc0102cd748959eebf1.jpg

@ edb47027:685bb004

🔸

@ 0e29efc2:ff142af2

Paid relays have the best incentive.

@ 32e18276:5c68e245

the only question is what the motivation is? also amazing he can keep up the lie for so long. just for fame? to stay out of trouble with the government after something he did at area 51, like the watch parties? that's the only thing that makes sense to me. maybe staying in the spotlight helps somehow.

@ 97c70a44:ad98e322

That shows up if one of the relays seems to be offline or slow. Better relay tracking is coming in the next release.

@ d91191e3:7efd4075

I've voted to ratify your merit request! problem: users can't log in or sign events https://github.com/nostrocket/problems/issues/1 https://github.com/nostrocket/problems/pull/4

@ a44dbc9a:b6c4bf4b

I can't read, but the vibes on this post just feel SO RIGHT

@ a38a5cd0:92b1b8f0

OK, they cut 50bps. Back to business, folks

@ c6f7077f:ad5d48fd

It might take some time, I'll start by rolling out the paywall feature, and then I'll speedily work on adding support for physical items and subscriptions.

@ ae1008d2:a166d760

This is a brilliant idea thank you Sugar very energy dense

@ a95c6243:d345522c

Achgut: Pager-Explosionen: Das Ende von Handys in Flugzeugen? 'Bedeutet die „Operation below the Belt“, mit der tausende von der Hisbollah genutzte Pager und andere elektronische Geräte gleichzeitig zum Explodieren gebracht wurden, das Ende von Handys und Computern in Flugzeugen? Experten erwarten tiefgreifende Auswirkungen auf die Luftfahrtindustrie.' https://www.achgut.com/artikel/das_ende_von_handys_und_computern_in_flugzeugen

@ c6f7077f:ad5d48fd

Thank you for taking the time to provide such comprehensive and useful answers. If I understand correctly, it should be something like this preview page, but with some modifications, such as multiple picture uploads for showcasing, markdown support for descriptions, and multiple subscription options, simple login. 🤔 It should include proper and elaborate feedback, perhaps through Nostr DM, optional email. And dark mode, of course https://i.imgur.com/Gdcdgeh.jpeg

@ a95c6243:d345522c

Handelsblatt: Neue Welle von Explosionen – Nun Handfunkgeräte betroffen 'Tausende Mitglieder der Hisbollah wurden am Dienstag verletzt, weil ihre Pager explodierten. Nun erschüttern erneut Explosionen den Libanon, diesmal sind es tragbare Funkgeräte.' https://www.handelsblatt.com/politik/international/libanon-neue-welle-von-explosionen-nun-handfunkgeraete-betroffen/100070711.html

@ c6f7077f:ad5d48fd

I'm rebuilding everything from scratch, aiming for a minimalist approach to selling physical products. Something like, it will include product previews with long-text descriptions and markdown support, as well as multiple image uploads for showcasing. There will be extra input fields for user addresses and other necessary details, which will be forwarded directly to your Nostr DM and possibly via email. It's entirely feasible; I just need time to get it right. This time, I want to perfect the monetization service. You will be the first early tester, I will really need your suggestion and recommendation.

@ cad139b1:f8e93001

Creación, validación y custodia. La completa descentralización económica se alcanza cuando participas en los 3 procesos https://m.primal.net/KqmV.jpg

@ f977c464:32fcbe00

GM!

@ a95c6243:d345522c

Tkp: Impfschaden: Biontech in Hamburg vor Gericht 'Während Biontech bekannt gibt, künftig den Fußballverein Mainz 05 zu sponsern, sitzt das Unternehmen in Hamburg auf der Anklagebank. Erstmals aufgrund des Covid-mRNA-Stoffes.' https://tkp.at/2024/09/17/impfschaden-biontech-in-hamburg-vor-gericht/

@ 32e18276:5c68e245

Our local search is on the main timeline when you pull down. We are moving this over to the profile/hashtag search box soon https://i.nostr.build/9RPEAh1VnHdPzHcM.jpg

@ a95c6243:d345522c

Bundesverfassungsgericht: Hessisches Verfassungsschutzgesetz teilweise verfassungswidrig Der Erste Senat des Bundesverfassungsgerichts hat 'entschieden, dass mehrere im Hessischen Verfassungsschutzgesetz (HVSG) geregelte Datenerhebungs- und Übermittlungsbefugnisse des Landesamts für Verfassungsschutz mit dem Grundgesetz unvereinbar sind, weil sie gegen das allgemeine Persönlichkeitsrecht (Art. 2 Abs. 1 GG in Verbindung mit Art. 1 Abs. 1 GG) in seiner Ausprägung als Schutz der informationellen Selbstbestimmung verstoßen.' 'Zwei der Beschwerdeführenden sind Mitglieder und Funktionsträger einer vom Landesamt für Verfassungsschutz als extremistisch eingestuften Organisation. Zwei weitere Beschwerdeführende vertreten als Rechtsanwälte Personen, die vom Landesamt beobachtet werden, weil ihnen die Zugehörigkeit oder Unterstützung ausländischer terroristischer Vereinigungen vorgeworfen wird oder sie der linksextremistischen Szene angehören. Ein weiterer Beschwerdeführer steht als freier Journalist häufig in Kontakt mit Personen, die unter Beobachtung des Landesamts stehen.' https://www.bundesverfassungsgericht.de/SharedDocs/Pressemitteilungen/DE/2024/bvg24-078.html

@ a44dbc9a:b6c4bf4b

nice

@ a38a5cd0:92b1b8f0

The downside of recording more video content in different locations? You'll have to rearrange your furniture at home. https://m.primal.net/Ktpj.jpg

@ b12deee2:afca6d50

Imagine if a government wanted to slowly & quietly dumb a countries population down, train them to be complacent and docile, and convince them that foolish entertainment and misdirection was more important than health & personal liberty. This would have to be done over decades, always with plausible deniability. They might do it by replacing real food with junk food, leading to lower testosterone levels, brain fog, mental illness & chronic aches and pains. They might actually try to convince The People that ultra-processed food was actually healthy. Does this sound familiar at all??

@ a95c6243:d345522c

https://www.nachdenkseiten.de/?p=120833

@ be39043c:4a573ca3

😀 lovely piece

@ a95c6243:d345522c

Thanks! Maybe I could check that tag limit ...

@ a95c6243:d345522c

Wegen Impfverweigerung inhaftierter Bundeswehrsoldat im Hungerstreik Oberfeldwebel Alexander Bittner wehrte sich gegen die für Soldaten obligatorische Covid-«Impfung». Deswegen wurde er verurteilt und am Montag auch verhaftet. Jetzt ist er in den Hungerstreik getreten. https://denkbar.substack.com/p/wegen-impfverweigerung-inhaftierter

@ 5c3d8f0d:9150e34c

Slide to the right 💃🕺

@ a95c6243:d345522c

https://t.me/happinessismyway/3492

@ a95c6243:d345522c

Great 👍

@ a44dbc9a:b6c4bf4b

💯 grapes next week

@ 80dfb565:325898f8

2/10/25

@ 26cdfd8d:245f55f1

Moneromaníacos são bem paranóicos mesmo.

@ dffd3ffc:5ade7be1

Discordの方、サーバ単位でアイコン変えたさあるな

@ 865b6bd3:a8bb83a2

Curioso pelo que está por vir. Se adicionassem features que justifiquem o aumento de preço, eu consideraria voltar.

@ a38a5cd0:92b1b8f0

Did not have this statement by BlackRock on my bingo card. There are some interesting finds in their latest #Bitcoin report.👀 It would be great if they could now clarify the IOUs and what Coinbase is doing. https://www.blackrock.com/us/financial-professionals/literature/whitepaper/bitcoin-a-unique-diversifier.pdf https://m.primal.net/KtjQ.png

@ 5c3d8f0d:9150e34c

💕 Bedminster ⛳️ https://image.nostr.build/b0f8844974ace62a42f6b0cbf88e65ece7099a5864ed68e7097dabc50b56d7dd.jpg

@ fe9edd5d:f158913b

焼肉きんぐだ

@ a38a5cd0:92b1b8f0

Brillant 😂😂😂

@ 5c3d8f0d:9150e34c

Everything cold 🧡 https://youtu.be/-BcId4_4vO4?si=VEAVyw1XYF_D28Um

@ 18483135:00cf44f6

# **Automata** ## **A Profound Existential Experience** _*This article is a Nostr-exclusive so please give it a boost if you think it’s worthy of one!_ https://image.nostr.build/e26a76603fbf3c764492dcb433632455f0882b6742bade6c29b4c05776c301c0.jpg The world of video games has come a long way since its inception, evolving from simple pixel-based arcade games to highly immersive experiences. However, the medium is still broadly considered to be not much more than entertainment. Even as a gamer, I used to agree with that statement, though some games did help shape who I am. I was a pretty lonely kid and certain game characters substituted as a father figure. I absorbed their values and even mimicked their behavior. And yet, at one point I stopped being interested in gaming. This happened around the same time I was “awakening” through Bitcoin, Austrian Economics and other meaningful topics. I no longer had any intention of wasting time on the medium as a means of distraction. It didn’t take me very long to suspect I might have just been looking for the wrong things. Instead of the best RPG, the best action, the best graphics, the best gameplay, … how about I look for games that people have found significant meaning in? As I browsed online through forums and blogs, particular discussions and comments really spoke to me, although they seemed a bit exaggerated at the time. Depression, existential crisis, temporary psychosis. These are not the kind of effects you’d expect people to have from a form of entertainment. But as I played them, I realized they weren’t kidding. These games challenged how I view myself, humanity, the world, life itself and even my own way of thinking. I went from being sick of gaming to finding profound and worthwhile experiences, all by simply changing what I was looking for. Now, I’m convinced that important topics will one day become more mainstream with the usage of the gaming medium. In the bottom of this note I will add a list of these games. They all deserve to be written about, but I will mainly focus on my experience with one in particular, the one that had the most impact on me. It’s one of those experiences that I can’t stop thinking about even after so many years, and I never will. This note is written out of sheer gratitude, as I feel indebted for the value I have received, and to spread awareness of its existence. Video games allow for hugely ambitious projects, but if one aspect feels off, the product as a whole will drastically decrease in efficacy. Just like certain movies, it tries to incorporate nearly all forms of art, but with the key difference that it places you directly in the story with varying degrees of control, decisions, and the consequences of those decisions. The tricky part is achieving harmony and synchronicity between the visual, audiovisual, writing, and story execution. Everything needs to feel connected and this requires immense skill and cooperation between the involved entities to execute successfully. Naturally, the depths of wisdom contained in books are unparalleled. But it really hits different with games like _Nier: Automata_, which encapsulates wisdom within a story that shreds one’s mind and heart apart, accompanied by music which I can only understate as “the sound of the human condition”. https://image.nostr.build/dbd569df611a8c2e7d0999873ae25db479ad78a49a532ba1d2f2385462884efb.jpg ## **Exploring The Underlying Themes** The first impression one may have when they look at Nier: Automata on the surface, is "hot android chicks fighting against machines". Everyone knows sex sells, but I dare say it is a rather typical Japanese media phenomenon where the female form is on the foreground but mind-boggling concepts are lurking behind it. I think a fair analogy to this is Bitcoin’s fiat price, where the prospect of wealth is the magnet that draws in people, but most of us know it is only the bait next to the rabbit hole. Much like in Nier, you’d miss out on all the incredible stuff if you didn’t look further than the hot androids. Anyway, you will no doubt notice I will be extremely vague about the story itself. Instead, I will focus on some of the underlying content as to provide proper context for potential players. The game takes place in 11945 AD, during a proxy war between human-made androids and alien-made machines. They were designed to serve a predetermined obligation. Don’t humans have a similar mechanism? Don’t we all feel like we need to serve a purpose, whether that is predetermined or not? Much of the game is about coping with the loss of purpose and the realization of an identity for yourself afterwards. Nihilism is the belief that nothing matters and everything is meaningless. Existentialism on the other hand, is the attempt to confront and deal with meaninglessness, as to not succumb to nihilism. An existentialist does not give up in the face of adversity, nor does he avoid responsibility. Albert Camus, for instance, believed the entire purpose of existential philosophy is to overcome absurdity. In other words, for man to triumph over the absurdity of existence. The nihilist says: I am a godless creature, there is no heaven or hell, there is no right or wrong. The existentialist says: you and I must figure out how to make life meaningful and good. We must, in fact, work (together) without cosmic aid to figure out what 'good' itself is, regardless of the existence or non-existence of a god. Even though the game is full of events which would turn anyone to a nihilistic mindset, the game counters this during the most significant ending sequence, ending E, where players are able to leave a message for other players to see. Since I won’t spoil any details, what I can allow myself to say is this: the game isn't telling you that our existence is ultimately meaningless. Instead, an event lets YOU and other players demonstrate that it is not. Life doesn't HAVE to be pointless. Humanity doesn't HAVE to treat freedom as a curse, as Jean-Paul Sartre proclaimed. Games don't HAVE to be silly little things, made to distract us from our own meaninglessness. The potential absence of a god doesn’t HAVE to be a negative circumstance. We're not doomed per se. We can treat our freedom as an opportunity to create our own futures. To craft happier endings. https://image.nostr.build/ae8ae25334dd725002c0e21644b956f401f92502e09fc1b547a1df24c49496a3.jpg ## **Mechanics** In the game, there are machines that take the form of real-life philosophers, because their specific work seemed most valuable to these machines. This is no different than us humans; we tend to absorb the views of the people whose words resonate with us. As such, we get to see a fresh perspective on certain philosophies, and how this might play out for machines is just another way of tuning our understanding of humanity. You will also encounter rather unfriendly historical figures in machine form, For example, the first boss battle is versus an enemy called… Marx. That’s right, Karl Marx is your first boss fight. He takes the form of an excavator arm, which is normally attached to another machine lifeform, called Engels. And yes, that’s a reference to Friedrich Engels, who aided Marx in the construction of the communist theory. They quite literally seized the means of production. In real life the duo was inseparable until Marx's death, at which point Engels was alone with his thoughts. Just as when you defeat the Engels unit in-game, it will be separated from its right arm, Marx. By defeating it, it will be immobilized with nothing to do but contemplate upon its past actions, and you can return to speak to it on multiple occasions, if you wish to do so. As I stated before, the game takes place in 11945 AD, so machines and androids are indeed extremely advanced. Some could be considered on par with the human gestalt in every way. As such a technologically advanced entity, your current state of being along with your memories and all that makes you “you”, can be backed up and uploaded into a blank compatible body unit. For this reason, a well known system among gamers called "auto-save" is non-existent here. Saving your game equals backing up your state of being at the time. Many core elements of the main narrative and relationships between the protagonists are based on the ability or inability to back up data. And since this plot point of the androids backing up their data is tied to the game’s save system, there is no auto-save. The creator of the game, Yoko Taro, has an aversion to ludonarrative dissonance, where elements of the game go in stark contrast with what the story is telling, so using the game’s mechanics as a narrative device to deliver main plot elements is exactly one of the ways to avoid this. Gameplay and story stay true to each other. That said, our past experiences and recollections define who we are. This raises questions about the nature of self-identity and personal growth. Whether you believe it is possible for non-organic beings to develop human-like consciousness, or in the eventual possibility of backing up and uploading said consciousness, is irrelevant. The goal here is to explore the human condition and deepen our appreciation for its complexity. The story unfolds over 3 major playthroughs, each of which are different. The first 2 playthroughs, though indeed different, are very similar as they tell the same part of the story but with additional context and information, as well as playing through the eyes of a different character. This is key to a proper transition into the powerful third part. Near the end, you gain the ability to redo certain events of the game so you can make different choices and see how this impacts that particular timeline. This part of the game is my favorite, as it allows a deep-dive into all the rabbit holes that are scattered throughout the game. Every time I thought I had seen the full truth or all there was to be seen, I kept making new discoveries. It felt very similar to figuring out all the lies and mechanics of the fiat system. I will now move on to discuss a few of the philosophers and how they are relevant in-game. It’s important to note that the game does not try to push any philosophical views on you. Instead, you are shown the pros and cons of certain values, thoughts, beliefs, and ways of living. You are not told how to live your life, but through storytelling you are shown the importance of responsibility and walking your own path. https://image.nostr.build/9054a12abb8895e1670a9cbbaad57189e9e2c9da9872ff4134a4dd29525de9a9.jpg ## **Friedrich Nietzsche** _"Everything that lives is designed to end. We are perpetually trapped in a never-ending spiral of life and death. Is this a curse? Or some kind of punishment? I often think about the god who blessed us with this cryptic puzzle.. and wonder if we'll ever get the chance to kill him."_ This is the game’s opening monologue by a female android called 2B. It is reminiscent of Samsara, a concept present especially in buddhism and hinduism, which describes the endless drifting of a futile existence that can only be stopped with true insight. 2B’s name is based on the famous speech in Shakespeare’s Hamlet _“To be or not to be”_ in which the character Hamlet contemplates death and suicide, weighing the pain and unfairness of life against the alternative. Nietzsche’s influence on this game is extremely obvious; in 2B’s monologue alone we can already see two major Nietzschean themes that tie into the Nier franchise. The first one is eternal return (or eternal recurrence). This is the concept which states that time repeats itself in an infinite loop, and that exactly the same events will continue to occur in exactly the same way, over and over again, for eternity. With a finite number of events and an infinite amount of time all things will repeat themselves forever. It is not known whether Nietzsche believed in the eternal return, or if it was merely used as a means to demonstrate his point. The second one, is on how to live life in a world without god(s). _“God is dead. God remains dead. And we have killed him.”_ For Nietzsche, the idea of what it is to be a human was up until a point aimed at a God. What it meant “to be” was derived from a God. As such, meaning was given to existence. However, societal and scientific progress "killed" God, or the need for one, and a human being could no longer see themself as an existence with a “true” purpose. This in turn, leads to the crisis of the concept of being a human, as it no longer holds as the notion of purpose. The androids in the game were created by humans, therefore we could say that humanity is their god. Humans are a natural phenomenon — androids are not. I am aware of the counterargument; since humans are a part of nature, anything we create could also be defined as natural, at least to a certain degree. I have no strong stance on this matter, but one could argue that when they die, their consciousness lives on because it shares an attachment to the natural world. One cannot say the same of an artificial consciousness. There is nothing for a machine to believe in after death. They know who their gods are. If their gods are gone, their objective goes with it, and they are left with absolutely nothing. Humans on the other hand have the “luxury” to believe in an afterlife, a rebirth, or simply an unknown. Machines do not, so if they are to survive life’s suffering, they must follow an ethic as stated by Nietzsche, who believed that if you want to live without a god, it is necessary to create your own values. As I stated before, much of the game is about coping with the loss of purpose and the realization of an identity for yourself afterwards. Some androids clearly resent the purpose they have been given. You, the player, can see how the story potentially ends and resent the game creators for it. You either accept the fate given to you, or you decide it cannot continue like this, and you fight to defeat the gods of the game to break free. https://image.nostr.build/04ecd8ec7ff19521f018a89febea0f17e8762ce38dec49bc99c11dbacef17aab.jpg ## **Pascal Blaise** _“When I consider the short duration of my life, swallowed up in the eternity before and after, the little space which I fill, and even can see, engulfed in the infinite immensity of spaces of which I am ignorant, and which know me not, I am frightened, and am astonished at being here rather than there; for there is no reason why here rather than there, why now rather than then. Who has put me here? By whose order and direction have this place and time been allotted to me? Memoria hospitis unius diei prætereuntis.”_ Pascal Blaise, a mathematician, physicist, and philosopher, is a significant figure of the 17th century. He was the inventor of the first mechanical calculator, the Pascaline, and as you may have guessed, the unit of pressure “Pascal” was named after him. Our existence is based on uncertainty, and there is no way to prove a god exists, or does not exist. Pascal chose to live his life as if god exists. You may be familiar with the philosophical argument “Pascal's wager”, which posits that individuals essentially engage in a life-defining gamble regarding the belief in the existence of God. After seeing countless of his comrades die in an ongoing war, Machine Pascal refused to take any more part in this endless cycle and decided to become fully pacifistic while dedicating himself to learn about humanity and teaching other machines about emotions. At one point, we see Pascal studying Nietzsche’s work (In real life Pascal preceded Nietzsche so this would be an anachronistic event, if it weren’t for the fact that these characters are timeless machine representations). _“It seems this Nietzsche was quite the profound thinker.. Or perhaps he skipped right past profound and went straight to crazy instead.. I’d best go see the world for myself instead of burying my head in books.”_ A wise choice indeed. I couldn’t help but think of Keynesian economists during this remark. Keynesians may have read very much about mainstream economics but they are completely oblivious as to how the world actually works. They are convinced that their statistics are causally linked and their formulas correct, despite the overwhelming evidence against it. They are blind to the destructive effects of their flawed beliefs. To quote Pascal: “It is man's natural sickness to believe that he possesses the truth.” https://image.nostr.build/08331072065a2568bbb52657d192fb2b6a71c79aacf5abe3d8525a16c65d9463.jpg ## **Jean-Paul Sartre** _“Existence precedes essence”_ This idea originated from a speech by Friedrich Schelling in December 1841, and can be found in the work of other philosophers such as Søren Kierkegaard in the 19th century, and Heidegger’s book _‘Being and Time’ _ in 1927. But it was philosopher Jean-Paul Sartre who worked out this concept in detail. “Existence precedes essence” is a disagreement with the traditional philosophical view that the essence (nature) of something is more fundamental and unchangeable than its existence. People create their own values and determine their own meaning in life, since they have no innate identity or value. This identity or value must be created by the individual himself. By performing the actions of which they are composed, they make their existence more substantial. To claim that existence precedes essence is to assert that there is no predetermined essence to be found in humans, and that an individual's essence is defined by the individual through how that individual creates and lives his or her life. As Sartre puts it in _Existentialism is a Humanism_: "man first of all exists, encounters himself, surges up in the world and defines himself afterwards". In 2009, philosophy professor James Webber interpreted Sartre's usage of the term essence not in a modal fashion, i.e. as necessary features, but in a teleological fashion, thus relating to the explanation of phenomena in terms of the purpose they serve rather than of the cause by which they arise. An essence is the relational property of having a set of parts ordered in such a way as to collectively perform some activity. For example, it belongs to the essence of a house to keep the bad weather out, which is why it has walls and a roof. Humans are different from houses because unlike houses they don't have an inbuilt purpose: they are free to choose their own purpose and thereby shape their essence, therefore their existence precedes their essence. When it is said that people define themselves, it is often perceived as stating that they can "wish" to be something and then be what they claim to be. According to Sartre, however, this would be a kind of bad faith. What is meant by the statement is that people are defined only insofar as they act, and that they are responsible for their actions. To clarify, it can be said that a person who acts cruelly towards other people is, by that act, defined as a cruel person and in that same instance, they (as opposed to their genes, for instance) are defined as being responsible for being this cruel person. Ofcourse, you can choose to act in a different way, and to be a good person instead of a cruel person. Here it is also clear that since people can choose to be either cruel or good, they are, in fact, neither of these things essentially. Jean-Paul's depiction in Nier: Automata parodies the real-life Sartre, who despite great acclaim for his philosophy famously disdained awards and recognition. Among other honors, he was awarded the 1964 Nobel Prize for Literature, but refused to accept it. I also see the resemblance with the game’s creator, Yoko Taro, who is known for playing down his achievements very much, calling his games shit for instance. Though he does so in a playful manner. Machine Jean-Paul takes the work of the human Jean-Paul so seriously that he ignores that the human versions had a life outside of philosophy. Or rather, whatever part of his life was not recorded or lost, would not exist to a machine. https://image.nostr.build/e8e5eff636b69c21d9e29610e2739712b8dc3329aa5de641035bc4d110f1cd70.jpg ## **Simone De Beauvoir** Simone de Beauvoir (who had a lifelong relationship with Jean-Paul Sartre) wrote of the example of a woman's identity going wrong if it is based on nothing but a man's affection. In-game, she was at one point a normal machine. But one day, she fell in love with the Jean-Paul machine. When he disregarded her, pleasing him and getting his attention became her obsession. She made it her goal to become beautiful. “Beauty is pretty skin,” Simone says. “Beauty is stylish accessories. Beauty is looking one’s best.” As time went on, and Jean-Paul still wouldn’t notice her, things went too far. Simone became desperate and consumed machines and androids to see if she could obtain beauty by digesting them. She even draped dozens of android corpses over her dress in a sickly decorative manner. Driven to madness by her obsession, Simone becomes a monster. And in the end, Jean-Paul still never noticed her. He still never looked her way. So yeah, I said I was not going to mention any more mechanics but looks like I lied; during the battle with Simone this theme is simulated, when you are unable to look at her with the camera at all, no matter what you do with the controls. And as the player deals enough damage to her outer case of morbid accessories, her true unappealing self is revealed. https://image.nostr.build/0b2fa1571ea9086e71a1d44200e898da8b2a4c2dbe22cd697a4df264f7d37f76.jpg ## **Immanuel Kant** Admittedly, I’m not deeply familiar with Immanuel Kant’s work but I know this much: Kant wrote of the importance of duty in moral action and the intent behind an action being more important than the end result. In the forest section in Nier: Automata, we see a sacrifice being made with good intent but with little result. The entire sequence is about exploring this concept. In the first playthrough you go through an area where all you see is the result of something. The second playthrough shows you the intent. One should always keep in mind that in many cases, be it in-game or in real life, we are only left with results to judge. Kant believed that when people refuse to judge and think for themselves, it’s due to a lack of courage to be independent. He strongly argued against the idea of saying “Why dare to push against the grain when you could simply follow the herd?” Yet this is the antithesis of what in-game Immanuel Kant represents. https://image.nostr.build/200539ff5506341a1fe54ac38fca757cd47c62eb2171fd1b8a405bea06b2e44f.jpg ## **Yoko Taro** The creator of the Nier franchise agrees with the existential viewpoint that our lives have no innate meaning whatsoever and that our existence is profoundly absurd. He also confesses that he’s not yet ready to accept the world as it is, and intends to keep trying to change it with his video games. As opposed to the majority of games, where many conventions of the game market inhibit creative freedom, he is keen in experimenting with the video game format. “Throughout his entire career, Taro Yoko has always felt disheartened by the image of humanity reflected in most big-budget video games, which propose the use of firearms as the principal means of action. Through his own work, from Drakengard to NieR: Automata, this artist attempts to explore the reasons behind our strange fascination with conflict. Is man so vicious that he must triumph, discriminate, hurt and kill even for entertainment? Within the great fields of ruin resulting from wars in which mankind battled against mankind, Taro Yoko perceives this “entertainment” as a way for hope, a horizon, a shield against evil.” _-- The Strange Works of Taro Yoko: From Drakengard to NieR: Automata Hardcover – June 1, 2019_ Yoko Taro is known for being quite the eccentric figure. He has an intense dislike for giving interviews and believes that game designers are not supposed to be entertainers or commentators on their work, and that the usual questions asked in traditional media interviews would be boring to the viewer. For this reason and others, he is anonymous. Nobody’s ever seen his face, and I think Yoko Taro isn’t even his real name. As for his work, he writes in a manner called "backwards scriptwriting", which he describes as starting with the ending first, then working backwards from there. He then creates central plot points that form emotional peaks in the narrative, adds details, then scatters them through the narrative so the player can build a suitable emotional connection. Many of his games reflect his own feelings about death and his socratic questioning of the concept. He also has an unconventional and creative approach to sharing extra information about his games. For example, inside the soundtrack there's a message that's coded in hexadecimal. When deciphered, you find it is a partial memory retrieved from one of the android protagonists. Good developers are able to produce good games, but it takes an exceptional individual or team of exceptional individuals, to craft a piece of work that is so emotionally powerful, so moving, that it transcends the medium of entertainment and leaves an unforgettable mark. https://image.nostr.build/f646ae3f6e12b16d48b2429551c4d293ceb8576bc89fefc507aad9a1c2ea1f19.jpg ## **If you made it this far, thank you for reading!** A few quick tips to fully enjoy this masterpiece.. For the sake of all that’s holy, play it in the original Japanese voiceover. The immersion gets quite broken if you don’t get to hear the proper emotion in the character’s voices. English subtitles are included of course. It is also an experience that’s most effective when you go through it all alone, as to allow for the most self-reflection and absorption. Quick echo of what I said on top: I would love it if this note got some visibility, it is a Nostr-exclusive article so please give it a boost if you think it’s worthy of one! Also, HI EVERYONE. I haven’t used my #introductions formally yet, so this is it! Now here is the list of games I said I was going to provide, not in any specific order, and a short description for some. ## **Must-play** Disco Elysium: The player controls a detective who suffers from amnesia and has to solve a murder case while navigating his own state of being and dealing with the consequences of past mistakes. One of the most unique elements in this game, is the fact that concepts such as logic, or various parts of your body such as your limbic system, actually converse with you. The Talos Principle: Like Nier: Automata, lots of self-reflection and a challenge to your sense of morality. Its gameplay however is based on problem-solving and presenting you with thought-provoking questions in a direct manner. The Talos Principle 2: A continuation of the events in the first game. ## **Semi must-play** Detroit: Become Human Lisa Bioshock Infinite Omori Oneshot Doki Doki Literature Club ## **Meaningful Anime** Since I’m writing about existential stuff anyway, I might as well add the relevant anime that I’ve watched. It doesn’t have the same level of impact on me as games do but I feel like this note wouldn’t be complete without mentioning them. Again, in no particular order: Neon Genesis Evangelion (Yoko taro also mentioned Nier: Automata was inspired by this anime) Serial Experiments Lain Ergo Proxy I know there’s plenty more gems out there but I haven’t gotten around to watching them yet. ## **Tags and stuff** #nier #nierautomata #philosophy #existentialism #game #gaming #games #gamestr #nihilism #story #storytelling #meaning #life #bitcoin #humanity Sources for some of the pictures (I didn’t find all sources, let me know if you made one of these so I can add your name) Deviantart: RPINr, Gasia112 Tagging some people in this of whom I’d expect they may be interested, apologies if I’m wrong. Special thanks to nostr:nprofile1qqs0njyrsum0tg9kz8kjc3v23tn6fqyq9e8v8rjja9jg8xrv53xwvysx870x6 for reading the article before I posted. nostr:nprofile1qqsxu35yyt0mwjjh8pcz4zprhxegz69t4wr9t74vk6zne58wzh0waycpzamhxue69uhhyetvv9ujumn0wd68ytnzv9hxgtcpz4mhxue69uhhyetvv9ujuerpd46hxtnfduhsz9thwden5te0dehhxarj9ehhsarj9ejx2a303dstl2 nostr:nprofile1qqstm84k2lp9knmvmf5gw88zvfvar7duvfpqfplryfystdn55ug2gkspz3mhxue69uhhyetvv9ujuerpd46hxtnfduq3qamnwvaz7tmwdaehgu3wwa5kuegpz4mhxue69uhhyetvv9ujuerpd46hxtnfduhsq2q4kj nostr:nprofile1qqsw4v882mfjhq9u63j08kzyhqzqxqc8tgf740p4nxnk9jdv02u37ncpz4mhxue69uhhyetvv9uju6mpd4czuumfw3jsz9nhwden5te0wfjkccte9ec8y6tdv9kzumn9wsq3yamnwvaz7tmsw4e8qmr9wpskwtn9wvql3tqm nostr:nprofile1qqsq08tj00hrmqz7y36csc02f5pgktn2x7q9lrd5t0uqgkleqqyev5qppemhxue69uhhjetnw3ezumt9qy2hwumn8ghj7cn9wehjumn0wd68yvfwvdhk6qg5waehxw309ahx7um5wghrzumpwshx7un8xegrky nostr:nprofile1qqsgwe49fmu6zu9nsc9uvm7k2k4myj6lmf6a04llxch5g3p0hh450wgpzamhxue69uhhyetvv9ujuurjd9kkzmpwdejhgtc0uk263 nostr:nprofile1qqsd308raal2s4zk4rf6kr3ksj9zget46uuw7rhvpdlqgxqaprdee0gpzamhxue69uhhyetvv9ujuurjd9kkzmpwdejhgtcg3eqjv nostr:nprofile1qqsqqx9hacelkffcgd3ecchzjtlvwq9xn2fmprhrwnzmm2t3exee2eqpzemhxue69uhhyetvv9ujuurjd9kkzmpwdejhgqg5waehxw309aex2mrp0yhxgctdw4eju6t0qyt8wumn8ghj7un9d3shjtnwdaehgu3wvfskueqrswwax nostr:nprofile1qqsrfud256c4pr0qh2elppkyh4dm676slpveg5wxu69vj40usdhre4spzamhxue69uhhyetvv9ujumn0wd68ytnzv9hxgtcpr4mhxue69uhkummnw3ezucnfw33k76twv4ezuum0vd5kzmp0qy2hwumn8ghj7un9d3shjtnwdaehgu3wvfnj7p6glz8 nostr:nprofile1qqsx45yrjtgm4glklaafgz0z4309gs6cwfja3d99s8rqvlvgagcptpqpzamhxue69uhhyetvv9ujuurjd9kkzmpwdejhgtcqpazrn nostr:nprofile1qqs8k0mcqd6sw3h524qn5gslszt9am9knmes3uh268dgnnpv3yfwj6qpzamhxue69uhky6t5vdhkjmn9wgh8xmmrd9skctcppemhxue69uhkummn9ekx7mp0qyw8wumn8ghj7mn0wd68yttsw43zuum9d45hxmmv9ejx2a30y7ph8a nostr:nprofile1qqsf9jl9scw0c5snmkylpfhkppzgd7z7dupul6ms5yl52kfcz9jr8wqpzamhxue69uhhyetvv9ujuurjd9kkzmpwdejhgtcdsgmt4 nostr:nprofile1qqs2vx0tw6tyhpc2pmddzv7mrwfpswm9xvejme245qe6mf8rz8t4jdgpf9mhxw309uexwmpjvdkk66ng09shy7nzwdmrymmfxfkk5an4van8gamzxa58vumwwf4h5eryd4hhzcntwfnkkutfwqehwctcw9jzummwd9hkuw358qmrjtcerr06x nostr:nprofile1qqsqarzpaw2xv4cc36n092krdsj78yll7n2pfx5rv7fzp4n9jhlsl2spzamhxue69uhkummnw3erytnp0faxzmt09ehx2aqpzamhxue69uhky6t5vdhkjmn9wgh8xmmrd9skctcprpmhxue69uhkv6tvw3jhytnwdaehgu3wwa5kuef0t872d5 nostr:nprofile1qqszfn67p6jlle0qsj7lwx2l0ylxpse83e0x56qe5euxtwgwnyzdfqgpz4mhxue69uhk2er9dchxummnw3ezumrpdejqzrthwden5te0dehhxtnvdakqzxmhwden5te0dehhxarj9e3kset9wdjhymmzda6zummjvug04fak nostr:nprofile1qqs004pykhq654rllnfqgdwxk9k7n3dtd9m4qkak5ex0su8rvxx9r6qpzamhxue69uhhyetvv9ujumn0wd68ytnzv9hxgtcpzemhxue69uhkummnw3ez6un9d3shjtnpwpcz7qg4waehxw309aex2mrp0yhxgctdw4eju6t09u3n7ry3 nostr:nprofile1qqspycgrhlwu3he9ddhq407h7duheqxucn4g3a7zlp7agyzzyz6dvhcpzemhxue69uhhyetvv9ujumn0wd68ytnwv46z7qg4waehxw309aex2mrp0yhxgctdw4eju6t09uq3zamnwvaz7tmwdaehgu3wwa5kuef0uxy8pv nostr:nprofile1qqsfrjd9ux5hgsg5cmlz6cdwfh5zv2024g8m2t6g9zqf83l8uqm0svspp4mhxue69uhkummn9ekx7mqpr3mhxue69uhkummnw3ezucnfw33k76twv4ezuum0vd5kzmqpzfmhxue69uhkummnw3ezu7nzvshxweczwanqt nostr:nprofile1qqszfcr2fxlce982jxcjekzptxa2974zq9h3dflpuhvvq6x9zussxrqpr4mhxue69uhkummnw3ezucnfw33k76twv4ezuum0vd5kzmp0qy88wumn8ghj7mn0wvhxcmmv9uq3wamnwvaz7tmjv4kxz7fwdehhxarj9e3xzmny9uy6lnne nostr:nprofile1qqst0mtgkp3du662ztj3l4fgts0purksu5fgek5n4vgmg9gt2hkn9lqpzamhxue69uhhyetvv9ujumn0wd68ytnzv9hxgtcpz4mhxue69uhhyetvv9ujuerpd46hxtnfduhsz9mhwden5te0wfjkccte9ec8y6tdv9kzumn9wshsweelva nostr:nprofile1qqsfye65t5530wq0wpllmdz23luhjxp9drhhh2syae6kk8cp6n3k3zspz4mhxue69uhhyetvv9ujuerpd46hxtnfduhszrnhwden5te0dehhxtnvdakz7qg3waehxw309ahx7um5wgh8w6twv5hsse3wct nostr:nprofile1qqs02tkmusfh735k5z8vje4p3v6v75he9dl38nq6tqghkz20fqgfuxspzemhxue69uhkzarvv9ejumn0wd68ytnvv9hxgqg6waehxw309ahx7um5wgh8xct5dphkzunyv4ezucm0d5q32amnwvaz7tm9v3jkutnwdaehgu3wd3skueqs94wzc nostr:nprofile1qqsp33aqewuw4avdyrrmn36pf2e26t4y8ayqrsl4hnq3w5258l2p3mspzpmhxue69uhkummnw3ezuamfdejszxnhwden5te0dehhxarj9e6hxetvv4ehxumgd96zucm0qyfhwumn8ghj7urpd9jzuumsdaex2tnhwv4rg6zx nostr:nprofile1qqst3pg6qm0a082glse9yd9pt6dydge2pxp2sga4fn0cy52tnvfqhggpzfmhxue69uhk7enxvd5xz6tw9ec82cspzpmhxue69uhkummnw3ezuamfdejszenhwden5te0ve5kcar9wghxummnw3ezuamfdejj7mnsw43rzutvddmk67ndwf585ur4v94nwcejvuukz6mkvdexsdmh0f4kgdm6vvmkvur9vemnjmnpdfmhqct4xcmrymn3v4skce340ylkyun0v9jxxctnws74gun4v5kx9kpe nostr:nprofile1qqsglcljg053zgvpsyrcwh23hjj08l84gdph42t329gweqpkxkynn3gpzamhxue69uhhyetvv9ujuurjd9kkzmpwdejhgtcawx4qt nostr:nprofile1qqsd3086elxcwhgevfgmp60u66fjl9swytj960nvcjxgnzgh42tkgkcpzamhxue69uhhyetvv9ujuurjd9kkzmpwdejhgtcqy3e2x nostr:nprofile1qqsdymmcuk25z9a4cefc5ttv3z3zjmr9cqu8wque6urf49uzd6cx49gppemhxue69uhkummn9ekx7mp0qy2hwumn8ghj7un9d3shjtnyv9kh2uewd9hj7qgmwaehxw309ahx7um5wghx7unpdenk2urfd3kzuer9wchsm634v2 nostr:nprofile1qqsg2zqd8wkhpnxu6lm5c2dyfa2mhpwte57apjae2ldp6g2mmwf3ypqpzamhxue69uhhyetvv9ujuurjd9kkzmpwdejhgtck0cpm9 n nostr:nprofile1qqsvnvvlln2ru6jlyweayugxecv7ftfdlzd6zqca63sh7x6ercggjegpz3mhxue69uhhyetvv9ujuerpd46hxtnfduq32amnwvaz7tm9v3jkutnwdaehgu3wd3skueqpp4mhxue69uhkummn9ekx7mqsu0f2w nostr:nprofile1qqsgydql3q4ka27d9wnlrmus4tvkrnc8ftc4h8h5fgyln54gl0a7dgspzemhxue69uhhyetvv9ujuurjd9kkzmpwdejhgqg5waehxw309aex2mrp0yhxgctdw4eju6t0qy2hwumn8ghj7un9d3shjtnddaehgu3wwp6kyfehcpn nostr:nprofile1qqsqfjg4mth7uwp307nng3z2em3ep2pxnljczzezg8j7dhf58ha7ejgpr3mhxue69uhkummnw3ezumt4w35ku7thv9kxcet59e3k7mgprdmhxue69uhhyetvv9ujucnfw33k76twwpshy6ewvdhk6qg5waehxw309aex2mrp0yhxgctdw4eju6t0yjtaea nostr:nprofile1qqs2xpwv3yngvx7auhr3hwm06w2tkn82dm6lt7ryq2eynlzuavxwygqppemhxue69uhkummn9ekx7mp0m8x8vn

@ dffd3ffc:5ade7be1

そういや前のアイコンは割と明るい赤色の背景だったな

@ 93c6ab5c:77e0090f

สวยคุ้มค่าเดินครับ 😁

@ a38a5cd0:92b1b8f0

This is the way!

@ a38a5cd0:92b1b8f0

He really is

@ 0497384b:059784a4

Need any help? 🙋‍♂️

@ 5f468793:0d48e8e7

背景のテイストは以前のものを踏襲している イベント前に変わりすぎるのもアレかと思って

@ a38a5cd0:92b1b8f0

Haha he must be cracking up right now 😂

@ 32e18276:5c68e245

fortunately

@ a38a5cd0:92b1b8f0

The clown of clowns 😂

@ d91191e3:7efd4075

It's quite the opposite. NATO is a net consumer invading the net producers becsuse they're trying to opt out of slavery.

@ 1e3aa975:80324f5f

vmess://eyJhZGQiOiAiMTA0LjE5LjU1LjQ5IiwgInYiOiAiMiIsICJwcyI6ICJcdTdmOGVcdTU2ZmQgQ2xvdWRGbGFyZVx1ODI4Mlx1NzBiOSIsICJwb3J0IjogMjA1MiwgImlkIjogImQ2YjZkOTgyLWQ1MmYtNDY1YS1iOTg4LTg1NjcwYjIzZjY0YSIsICJhaWQiOiAiMCIsICJuZXQiOiAid3MiLCAidHlwZSI6ICIiLCAiaG9zdCI6ICJjZG4xLmZyZWVncmFkZWx5Lnh5eiIsICJwYXRoIjogImdpdGh1Yi5jb20vQWx2aW45OTk5IiwgInRscyI6ICIifQ==

@ a38a5cd0:92b1b8f0

Who knew ETF and Gold Bros also have a sense of humor 😂😂😂 https://m.primal.net/KteV.png

@ 50d94fc2:df281d63

Blot out your imagination. Turn your desire into stone. Quench your appetite. Keep your mind centered on itself. – MA

@ a38a5cd0:92b1b8f0

When ETHBTC falls under 0.04, you have to become creative to survive. Don’t be silly folks, #Bitcoin only 🙌 https://m.primal.net/Ktbz.mp4

@ edb47027:685bb004

The Glee/VP whitehouse have no appreciation for how patient and tempered Russia has been in response to the USA continued provocations.

@ 5112cd62:d623ec49

My question is, after visiting the site, what happens if I actually call the operator?

@ 76dd32f3:70407698

So is anyone working on a self hosted software that takes a lightning address and converts and sends to a monero address?

@ 225bd271:6825fcc8

SAGA 短时触及 2.51 USDT，24 小时涨幅为 24.67% Foresight News 消息，据 Bitget 行情显示，SAGA 短时触及 2.51 USDT，现报价 2.47 USDT，24 小时涨幅为 24.67%。 https://foresightnews.pro/news/detail/54004

@ a95c6243:d345522c

Telepolis: Pager-Explosionen: Die tödliche Manipulation der Kommunikation der Hisbollah 'Technologie als Waffe: Neun Todesopfer und über 2500 Verletzte. Miliz, Behördenvertreter und Experten machen den israelischen Geheimdienst Mossad verantwortlich. Ein beispielloser Angriff auf die Hisbollah erschütterte am Dienstag den Libanon. Tausende Pager, die von Mitgliedern der schiitischen Miliz genutzt wurden, explodierten simultan und forderten mindestens neun Todesopfer und über 2.500 Verletzte.' https://www.telepolis.de/features/Pager-Explosionen-Die-toedliche-Manipulation-der-Kommunikation-der-Hisbollah-9876399.html

@ 769f03d2:2b3684f3

AGREE! HAPPY TO TEST OR HELP WHERE I CAN 👨‍💻

@ ae1008d2:a166d760

Gn https://image.nostr.build/57588333cccbaeba2ceec9e31d137c565639cb5aa048ccc1f71fcc3d6092ef4b.jpg

@ d7f0e391:496cb731

Did you know that ⚡️Lightning Network specifications are called BOLTs while 🥜Cashu Protocol specifications are called NUTs? Nuts and Bolts 🫶 https://github.com/lightning/bolts https://github.com/cashubtc/nuts

@ a95c6243:d345522c

Tkp: Pager-Terror im Libanon – Geräte in Europa mit Sprengstoff befüllt 'Etwa 5000 Pager der Taiwan Firma Gold Apollo sollen in Europa mit 20 Gramm PETN-Sprengstoff befüllt worden sein. Laut Sky News sei der Geheimdienst Mossad der Auftraggeber. Laut US-NSA-Whistleblower Edward Snowden handelt es sich um einen Terrorakt, der in anderen Städten der Welt einen massiven Aufschrei der westlichen Medien zur Folge hätte.' https://tkp.at/2024/09/18/pager-terror-im-libanon-geraete-in-europa-mit-sprengstoff-befuellt/

@ 26cdfd8d:245f55f1

Exagero. Há pelo menos 6 fusos diferentes para quem diz GM.

@ a95c6243:d345522c

NachDenkSeiten: Zur üblen Propaganda von Wikipedia – z. B. belegt mit dem Eintrag zu den NachDenkSeiten 'Die Unterzeile bei Wikipedia lautet: „Die freie Enzyklopädie“. Das sollte korrekter formuliert werden. Treffender wäre: „Die konsequent manipulierende Enzyklopädie“. Wenn Sie die NachDenkSeiten öfter mal lesen, dann werden Sie diese Kennzeichnung verstehen. Wenn Sie nämlich bei Wikipedia „NachDenkSeiten“ eingeben, dann erscheint folgender Text: „Ursprünglich als wichtiger Bestandteil einer „Gegenöffentlichkeit“ gelobt, wird der Website seit etwa 2015 jedoch zum Teil vorgeworfen, Verschwörungstheorien zu verbreiten, etwa zum Russisch-Ukrainischen Krieg seit 2014 oder zur Corona-Pandemie.“ – Haben Sie auf den NachDenkSeiten zum Krieg zwischen der Ukraine und Russland und zur Corona-Pandemie Verschwörungstheorien gelesen?' https://www.nachdenkseiten.de/?p=121427 https://image.nostr.build/5948431a0a0f804ae05e30296bf797dc7cd015c0bc3252a2da4757b476fe110a.png

@ d7f0e391:496cb731

I just paid for lunch with #Cashu at a restaurant in Prague and it was amazing! All I needed was the eNuts - Nutshell - LNbits - LND - Confirmo - Qerko stack 😅

@ a95c6243:d345522c

Süddeutsche: Meta verbannt russischen Staatssender RT von seinen Plattformen 'Für Russland wird es künftig etwas schwieriger, Lügen und Propaganda in westlichen Ländern zu verbreiten. Meta, der Mutterkonzern von Facebook, Instagram und Whatsapp, verbannt den russischen Staatssender RT, die Nachrichtenagentur Rossija Segodnja und angeschlossene Organisationen weltweit von seinen Plattformen. Ein Sprecher begründet die Entscheidung auf Nachfrage mit „ausländischer Einflussnahme“.' https://www.sueddeutsche.de/wirtschaft/meta-facebook-rt-russland-propaganda-lux.Gzau7a1UZX4AmCt1g93ycz

@ 8c592393:5c132608

骨までは斬らないが重傷までは持っていくの馬券を買っています。コロプラもそんな感じだったし

@ a95c6243:d345522c

Bastian Barucker, Berliner Zeitung: Beruhte die Corona-Impfkampagne auf der Vorspiegelung falscher Tatsachen? 'An den Daten der Impfstoffhersteller gab es früh Kritik. Auch die RKI-Protokolle dokumentieren viele Unsicherheiten. Warum warben Politiker trotzdem für die Impfung?' https://www.berliner-zeitung.de/open-source/corona-impfkampagne-beruhte-sie-auf-der-vorspiegelung-falscher-tatsachen-li.2253739

@ ae1008d2:a166d760

I stopped using primal awhile ago due to this.

@ 0f389bba:9b3f148f

🌊 SURF 'N TURF 🏝️ -THE ISLAND LIFE- NOSTR PRIMAL 💜🧡❤️ GROW NOSTR APOCALYPSE ANONYMOUS by ATOSHI ANARKOMOTO The iconic Monarch butterfly is now officially an endangered species in North America. 🦋 Among the causes of their steep decline, the lack of milkweed (their caterpillar's host plant and exclusive food source) in undeniably the main one and by far. Together, we can reverse this course. Together, we can plant milkweed seeds and give monarchs a much needed breather. Fall is the best season to plant milkweed. Our cold winters create physical and chemical reactions in milkweed seeds and increase their germination rates the following Spring. It's a small but very useful gesture, plus it makes a great gift for your loved ones! Monarchs will surely thank you for it by paying you a visit next Spring . Credits Goes to the respective Author ✍️/ Photographer📸 🐇 🕳️ #Bitcoin #Satoshis #Freedom #Apocalypse #Music #Movies #Philosophy #Literature #Grownostr #Stoicism #Nature https://m.primal.net/KuVS.jpg

@ 32e18276:5c68e245

true, safari has closed the gap. I stopped using chrome awhile ago. it's simple, and their reader feature is great.

@ a8a0654f:a6c5290d

vamos lá, hipótese: você amealhou um valor razoável na sua coldwallet, agora você quer se mudar para aquela fazenda no interior e passar a vida brincando de fazendinha, alimentado os seus com comida boa e vida ao ar livre... aí tem o detalhe: o estado te odeia, ele quer saber de onde veio seu BTC, como você comprou, onde você liquidou, como você adquiriu sua terra, exige que você coloque brinco nos seus bovinos e ruminantes, registre seus cavalos, pague a documentação daquela caminhonete a diesel 1991, pague o ITR, registre a propriedade no Incra, faça a reserva legal, tenha cadastro no CCIR e se for produzir para vender, tenha talão de produtor. --- o sonho Bitcoinheiro médio, faz sentido sendo no Brasil?

@ a38a5cd0:92b1b8f0

Editing more #Bitcoin content for nostr:npub1sqzr42dj8vx32yd5jcvvl3ytux45kl0etgf6y2ymjvmd7lqmuwmqk9vk7v 💪 https://m.primal.net/KseO.jpg

@ 2ddc90c9:01549103

She conducted the white sock test in Dubai, which has been voted one of the cleanest cities in the world. https://t.co/XnmEAKENg4 https://video.twimg.com/ext_tw_video/1836402423016886272/pu/vid/avc1/720x1280/XXu8_85ALL6gB34Q.mp4?tag=12

@ 97c70a44:ad98e322

Uh oh, it's an Apple Enjoyoors day. Maybe I'll just log off.

@ a38a5cd0:92b1b8f0

Oder die noch bessere Idee wäre, #Bitcoin zu kaufen und auf der Bilanz der SNB zu halten! 🔥 https://m.primal.net/Ksam.png

@ 7aebaeea:7caaf05a

nostr:npub1teawtzxh6y02cnp9jphxm2q8u6xxfx85nguwg6ftuksgjctvavvqnsgq5u Verifying My Public Key: " @davidforil"

@ a38a5cd0:92b1b8f0

Yes 😂😂😂

@ 0e29efc2:ff142af2

What’re your thoughts on K8?

@ c21827da:118337be

First time traveling through mainland Italy. Lucky Airbnb find with a great view. https://image.nostr.build/5c8103d3611a0474827a36c29ce965fe67d6869d6872a6b01522641265dcf22b.jpg

@ a95c6243:d345522c

Handelsblatt: Unternehmen nutzen Pleitewelle für Übernahmen mit Rabatt 'Die Zahl der Insolvenzen in Deutschland steigt. Die Schwäche der Konkurrenz nutzen manche Firmen, um zuzukaufen. Innerhalb der Unternehmen steigt derweil der Druck zur Transformation.' https://www.handelsblatt.com/unternehmen/mittelstand/familienunternehmer/insolvenzen-unternehmen-nutzen-pleitewelle-fuer-uebernahmen-mit-rabatt/100065788.html

@ 5f468793:0d48e8e7

一周回って有りな気がしてきた https://image.nostr.build/f0e19244809b2a3e8c16ed628f5b6545bdbe112cece3585e82cf540573955379.png

@ df8f0a64:057d87a5

パラワールドは一向に進化しないポケモンへの回答みたいな評価が一時期出てたけど、ポケモンがお前らゲームオタクのほうを向いて商売するわけないだろバカとしか思わなかった

@ a95c6243:d345522c

Norbert Häring: Verbraucherschützer protestieren gegen Digitalzwang im Verkehr 'Der Verbraucherzentrale Bundesverband (vzbv), europäische Verbraucherschützer und weitere Verbände appellieren an Bundesregierung, Bahn und öffentliche Verkehrsunternehmen, niemanden durch die Digitalisierung des Ticketverkaufs von Bus- und Bahnreisen auszu­schließen. Ähnliche Appelle gab es bereits von anderen Verbändekoalitionen, doch Bahn und Verkehrsminister geben sich bisher hartleibig.' https://norberthaering.de/news/verbraucherverbaende-bahn/

@ 4a827f52:a96cef7d

#grownostr #biochar just ground up another 10 gallons or so of biochar. Was a little drier than I’ve done in the past and was able to grind everything without cleaning the chopper halfway through. I’ve got about 30 gallons of biochar on hand now. Mainly for compost worms, garden beds and will put in my next bioreactor. https://image.nostr.build/969ad124d114d664cb62c8ec9abf31cce0e2e47894be5e303c55c2c308ef1984.jpg https://image.nostr.build/086eb8e61096d8e20dcbea054881492f9397eeb5b52e787c9175f5e1bb96fef8.jpg https://image.nostr.build/9b443dc59f9d7b217f094c01e456d50b662ad421e6c3ba7e9d55924c79c8f959.jpg https://image.nostr.build/14489fc84f1a3052f82ab4c135e1eed92c669d1c89eb21b453dc61da1fa2ac45.jpg

@ 23a520d5:c984e15b

It’s the job of node runner to filter spam on Bitcoin. nostr:note18hauk33g9jpgu3tfj569s9xu9snz9f73tkyefzsymf5asazlrmvqqg52v5

@ 8aaa577c:5bac596c

Test

@ a38a5cd0:92b1b8f0

I never thought I would see something good on CNN, but here we are. #Bitcoin https://m.primal.net/Kreg.mp4

@ 17538dc2:71ed77c4

GM

@ c3e45c03:585805d5

with a transalator....

@ 9727846a:00a18d90

只关注大波吧